Who should i choose!!!!!!?

.Right now i,m loving the single life, here is where its get confusing i,ve had a crush on this handsome guy back in college and finally we r all grown he states is is very much into me but the thing is we went out like 5 times and its always I love you, I want to spend the rest of my life with you then BAM!! at the end of the date he only calls me like once every two weeks, when i ask why he doesn,t call me often he claims he is phone shy should i believe this? because when he is around me we have a grand time together (NO JUST KISS EVERY NOW AND THEN), thats not all then came nother guy who is really sweet he calls me everyday and night he makes sure i,m alright especially if i,m sick, he keeps doing things to show me/ remind me how much he loves me has a very good Job and he is drop dead gorgeous Jeeze he makes me feel special but the problem is that he is just broke up with his girlfriend after 3 yrs..Should i be concerned because i like them both but number one guy has a communication problem (doesn,t call as often as i think he should) number 2 guy well he is just coming out of a relationship..HeLP!!!!! be honest